Good luck, touch wood, insh-allah
February 18, 2010
Last night, while ironing, I watched a programme about the Home Office. It’s the first in a series about the three great offices of state—the Home Office, the Foreign Office and the Treasury. Kim was filling in her job application on-line, and I had just come in from the Prayer Meeting. I saw there was ironing to be done, and decided to tackle it.
I hate just ironing. I have to be watching or listening to something at the same time. So I booted up the lap-top and went, first, to the Reformed Forum, an on-line chat show, hosted by Camden Bucey. If you don’t know it you should look it up. It’s only because of this show that I know what are the current hot topics in the Reformed world! They usually also review any new publications which may be of interest to their listeners. How these guys get the time to read so much I don’t know. Probably they aren’t notching up a couple of funerals per week.
Last night I listened to an introduction to Karl Barth’s theology. Having studied theology at a Scottish university I’m not entirely ignorant of what Barth is about, but the discussion was useful in that there were questions asked which had arisen in my mind too, and were answered. For example, how do Barthians escape the charge of being universalists? Answer, they may try to wriggle out of it, but not convincingly.
Anyway, after that discussion, there were still plenty of clothes to attend to, so I turned to BBC I-Player. I’m the kind of person I-Player was invented to serve. For me, it stands along side the Answering Machine as among the greatest inventions ever. It was getting late, and there was absolutely nothing on TV that I wanted to see. The programme about the great offices of state was just the right subject and the right length of time.
The programme was interesting in itself. But the reason I’m writing about it is because of something Jack Straw said. Jack Straw was New Labour’s first Home Secretary, and apart from Gordon Brown, is the only member of Tony Blair’s original Cabinet never to have been out of office. I wonder why. During the course of the interview he used the word or phrase “Insh-allah”.
I’d never heard someone who is not a Moslem use that phrase before. I believe it means “God willing”. Mr. Straw used it in a context in which others would have said “touch wood”. He meant “if we’re lucky”. Here’s what I’m thinking. Mr. Straw is not a Moslem; I think he is an atheist. This being so, why did he use that phrase? He is MP for Bolton, with many Moslems as constituents and I understand he has worked hard at building a good relationship with them. Has he merely picked up the phrase? Is he using it casually? If so, do Moslems mind?
Or, has he developed the habit of using the phrase in order to show familiarity with the it? It’s a way of demonstrating solidarity with his constituents; he has adopted some of their language. Again, what do Moslems think of that; for if this is the case, it could be considered a rather cynical ploy. Do devout Moslems hear him bandy about a phrase that actually contains meaning for them, and do they cringe, as real Christians cringe when we hear the Lord’s name used in vain? I’m just wondering.
February 23, 2010 at 2:34 pm
Sorry you seem to find the simple things difficult
I will explain the Bartian position to you very simply.
Logically, “some” simply means “not all”. In our statements that God has elected some to eternal life, all that is saying is that it is not necessarily all. The Bible tells us there is “one doomed to destruction, so that the Scripture would be fulfilled”. John 17:12.
There is therefore one who is elected for destruction
If you want to know more I suggest that you read the relevant section of the Dogmatic. Barth writes on the topic in his accustomed length. Unfortunately I sold my set when I retired so I can’t quote the passage
We also have the problem of a just God creating large numbers of people who are condemned to fail but that one was identified by Burns over 200 years ago.
February 23, 2010 at 8:27 pm
I’d never heard someone who is not a Moslem use that phrase before.
Curiously, the person who I know who uses it most often is a Presbyterian who used to be a missionary in the Middle East. Christian Arabs use it regularly – whether casually, or in the spirit of James 4.15, I do not know. It has just become part of the language, a bit like “God only knows” or “God bless” or even “Good-bye” in English. Some of these phrases make me cringe more than others, and I suppose it is the same with other Christians. Knowing how another Christian will react to certain phrases is not easy. Knowing how a Muslim will react is even more difficult. Who would have guessed that calling a teddy bear “Mohammed” would be highly offensive?